And finally, you can view your Pressimus profile by clicking on your profile image, and selecting your profile, and you can customize your Pressimus settings by selecting settings.
Watch quick explainer video
Finish
X

Request Invitation




Submit
Close
Submit
Stream by
The Interpreter
@Interpreter_Mag
Russian-to-English translation journal, with original analysis and commentary on Russia's foreign & domestic policy.
Interpreter_Mag
Russia Update: December 23, 2016

Publication: Russia Update
Readability View
Press View
Show oldest first
The Interpreter
@Interpreter_Mag
Russian-to-English translation journal, with original analysis and commentary on Russia's foreign & domestic policy.
Interpreter_Mag
Human Rights Activists Say 4.5 Year Prison Sentence Too Harsh for Moscow University Student Who Tried to Join ISIS

The Moscow District Military Court sentenced Varvara Karaulova, 20, a former philosophy student at Moscow State University, to 4.5 years for attempting to join ISIS after meeting a recruiter online, TASS reported.

As we reported, Varvara was an honors student from an affluent and well-connete family who studied Islam in cultural studies courses. She set off for Turkey after a man who gave his name as Airat Samatov who said he was an ISIS fighter convinced her online he would marry her. She was stopped on the Syria border by Turkish authorities and extradicted to Russia where she was jailed on charges of assisting terrorists.

The case was widely covered by Russian media, as public fears grew of ISIS snatching away Russians even without any background as Muslims.


Taking into account the time she already served in pre-trial detention, Karaulova will serve 3 more years and four months. The prosecutor had originally requested 5 years and a fine. The judge ruled that Karaulova could only be rehabilitated in isolation from society in prison. Since she had contacted ISIS on her own and had informed them of the FSB's actions, and had illegally left Russia and joined a terrorist group, she could not be left at large. "She went to Syria to take part in combat, realizing that this was a question of terrorist activity," said the judge.

In her final statement, Karaulova apologized both to her parents and to law-enforcers, saying her brush with ISIS was a "teenage rebellion," BBC Russian Service reported.

The sentence was based on Karaulova's own confession. The judge said that her claims that her testimony was made under pressure were contradictory and "didn't correspond to reality." Her lawyer, Sergei Badamshin, has appealed the sentence.

Varvara's father, Pavel Karaulov, said the sentence was based on her confessions which she had revoked after she changed lawyers. Her mother said the case was "a show trial."

Karaulov said, "We have a punitive state, a brutal one." He pointed out that not a single person in the chain of people his daughter dealt with associated with ISIS were identified. He also noted that it was unfair to sentence his daughter to more than 4 years, when actual fighters in ISIS who had taken part in combat got the same sentence.

He also complained about being misled by the Investigative Committee, and specifically former spokesman Vladimir Markin, who had said that his daughter would be a witness, not a suspect; no immunity was granted to such a witness, as it turned out. He said he now regretted cooperating with authorities so extensively as it didn't pay off, and his daughter had only incriminated herself.

Kira Karaulova, Varvara's mother said that all the statements both she and her ex-husband as well as her daughter had made were doubted, but the FSB's own statements were not. She now felt she had made a mistake in cooperating with the authorities. She also wondered if the recruiter was in fact an FSB provocateur, given that no evidence about him was ever brought up at the trial.

"We didn't expect such a degree of injustice," Pavel concluded. He said they would appeal the case to the European Court of Human Rights

Alexander Verkhovsky, head of the SOVA center who tracks extremist movements in Russia said in a comment on his Facebook page that while it was correct to criminalize Karaulova's attempt to join an actually dangerous terrorist organization, her sentence seemed excessive. He believed that if she were sent home, there would be less risk that she would radicalize. There are so many radical Muslims on the verge of joining ISIS or similar extremist groups that you could not jail them all, he said. So "an effective mechanism of 'return' is needed," i.e. to reintegrate them with society. Heavy prison sentences don't achieve that goal.

Ekaterina Sokirianskaia, Project Director for Russia & North Caucasus of the International Crisis Group commented that there were only a few programs for re-entry and job placement of fighters in Ingushetia and Dagestan and more often former fighters made unofficial agreements with the local FSB to return. On her Facebook page, Sikiranskaia said she believed the sentence was "too harsh" and made the government appear as a "soulless, punitive machine" once again. She noted that Karaulova's father was a former FSB officer himself, and some were pointing out that now he experienced the treatment he had meted out to others, and was stupid to have trusted the government.

She commented that the government had no choice but to sentence her, however, given that she had not turned herself in but was caught, and had also attempted to contact her recruiter and warn him of the FSB's actions. Even so, she could have been sentenced to time served in pre-trial or handed a suspended sentence, given that she confessed and cooperated with the government. She also said her father, Pavel Karaulov had no choice but to cooperate with the FSB as his daughter was already abroad and he could not obtain her return without their help. At least this way she will emerge from prison alive, whereas she might have risked her life in ISIS.

The sentence was also meant to serve as an object lesson to the public, that any flirtation with ISIS could lead to a stiff prison term. But it also signaled even to a disenchanted radical that he could not return to Russia, and that Russia was continuing to address the problem of jihadism as only a criminal matter. An opportunity was lost to have Karaulova serve as a speaker to deter young people from ISIS, as a peer would be more persuasive than government officials. 

Karaulova would hardly de-radicalize in prison, said Sokirianskaia, as all conditions there served rather to create ultra-radicals; now her case would prove that cooperation with the government didn't work to lighten one's sentence.

-- Catherine A. Fitzpatrick 


The Interpreter
@Interpreter_Mag
Russian-to-English translation journal, with original analysis and commentary on Russia's foreign & domestic policy.
Interpreter_Mag
Putin Echoes Trump, Saying 'A Guy on a Couch' May Have Hacked DNC - and Other Highlights from Press Conference

President Vladimir Putin gave his annual marathon press conference today December 23, his most popular of such events throughout the year because journalists -- both loyalist state and pro-Kremlin media as well as critical independent media -- get to ask a lot questions, sometimes quite pointed.

Putin went 3 hours and 50 minutes this year -- not his personal best, but given the prevalence of more soft-ball questions this year, it was long enough to make a reporter from the Guardian (which ran a live blog) say his shoulder hurt, and prompted Gazeta (which live-blogged in Russian) to say "Boorrring..."

Here is the full video (in Russian):

The Twitter parody account summed up the frustrations reporters increasingly have with this format: 

Reporters traditionally try to get attention to themselves in the throng by wearing funny hats and holding up big signs. 

Translation: Russian journalists have come to Putin's annual press conference with his portrait, Trump and the sign "Putin -- this is outer space."

Translation: Annnnd the winner in the nomation for Best Poster.

The reporter is holding up a picture of Boyaryshnik, the lotion containing methanol that poisoned to death at least 72 people in Irkutsk Region who drank it as an "alcohol surrogate". Putin's response to a question about the tragedy was to imply that people -- including "someone from a foreign country" simply wanted to get rich off people, Gazeta reported.

Likely the topic that got the most headlines both in the West and in Russia was Putin's interference in the US elections. Here Putin brushed aside any claims that Russia -- and he personally -- was involved in the hack of the Democratic National Committee (DNC) and other institutions related to the US elections and said it "could be some sitting guy on a couch." 

As the Guardian reported:

On hacking the US election, Putin says that he won’t reveal his private conversations with Obama. He says: “Losers always look for ways to accuse someone else. The always forget the most important thing. Let’s say some hackers hacked Democratic emails. As Trump said: “Who knows who did it?”

Putin repeats Trump’s comments that “maybe it was some guy sitting on a couch who did it”. He says that “the truth came out”. We discovered that the Democrats were manipulating the election to help Hillary Clinton and hurt Bernie Sanders, Putin says. 

Putin spoke in so much detail about the US elections issue on resignations that followed the disclosures and the "faithless electors" that it almost appeared as if he were trying to imply he personally managed Russia's interference in them. He even said that Russia was among the few countries to know Trump was going to win.

Russia is expected to continue to gain an advantage from the Trump administration.

The election system is "archaic" although "America is a great country," Putin commented.

An acerbic tweet following Putin's  scathing remarks about the US:


The picture on the left shows Obama talking with Putin on the margins of a world summit meeting. The painting on the left is a famous Russian art work depicting Lenin meeting with the peasant supplicants.

Even when Trump tweeted about the need for increased US nuclear defense, virtually at the same time Putin was making his own call for greater nuclear strength for Russia although claiming Russia "wouldn't start a nuclear war," he shrugged, as if to say this is what great statesmen do.

Set as default press image


Putin says Trump's statement on nuclear weapons no surprise

Politics | Fri Dec 23, 2016 | 5:03am EST MOSCOW Russian President Vladimir Putin said on Friday that a statement by U.S. President-elect Donald Trump about the need for the United States to boost its nuclear capabilities was not a surprise and was normal.

View full page →
Dec 23, 2016 20:37 (GMT)

Certainly there seemed to be more soft-ball questions this year than in past, to the point that Gazeta commented sarcastically about one reporter's query about environmental issues the government was handling -- with celebratory coverage by the press -- that it was a "question-boast."

On Syria:

Without Russia's involvement, Turkey and Iran couldn't cooperate; Aleppo is the "largest humanitarian action in the world," although impossible without Turkey and Iran -- and of course Russia. 

Kurdistan24 asked about Putin's attitude toward Kurdish independence, and he noted "the courage of the Kurds" but called for acting "within international law". He added that the rights of the Kurds would be guaranteed, but in what form would depend on Iraq and the Kurds themselves; Russia would not interfere in an internal Iraqi issue. 

On Russian Economy:

When a journalist comments that 2016 has been "a turbulent year" for the economy, Putin replies that “everything is relative” and “we have to look at macro-economic indicators”. GDP was down last year by 3.8%, Putin says, but predicts the fall in 2017 will be 1%. In short, the economy is “developing positively”.

The budget was planned with oil at $40 per barrel; now it's at $55 per barrel, providing 1 trillion 750 billion rubles for the budget, but refrained from speculating about how high oil might go.

On Sechin's Suing of Independent Press

Putin was unapologetic about reporters' concern over the chilling overreach of his close crony, Igor Sechin, CEO of Rosneft, who has successfully sued Novaya Gazeta, Vedomosti and RBC over their critical articles.

“What else can he do to defend his honour and dignity? He goes to court, like in any other civilised country,” Putin says. The court has ruled and this is "normal," said Putin.

On Murder of Boris Nemtsov

Five Chechens are currently on trial for the murder of opposition leader Boris Nemtsov in February 2015. But journalists asked about their superior commanders and whether Ruslan Geremeyev, deputy commander of the Sever battalion in Chechnya, would be summoned.

On Heavy Treason Sentence for Woman Who Sent Text About Russian Military Vehicles Headed to Georgia

An RTV journalist, after first asking a smarmy question about what was wrong and hypocritical with American democracy tacked on a query about a 7-year sentence for treason given to a Russian woman who texted to a friend the news that Russian military armor was headed toward Georgia, back at the time of the Russian-Georgian war in 2008. As we reported, there have been a spate of such cases.

Putin first claimed that the Russian judiciary was "independent," which is hardly the case, then went on to say that he felt the sentence was too harsh as well and he would look into the circumstances. 

On Family Violence

Russian liberal media has been covering with concern a State Duma law amendment that would decriminalize some domestic violence. 

Asked about juvenile justice, Putin said "children should not be spanked" and the state should not interfere in the family, promising to return to this issue. 

On Cultural and Political Controversies 

Asked about the conflict over the Yeltsin Center, where some conservatives have protested about a "too negative" portrayal of history at the exhibits there, Putin took the opportunity to say he was against "aggravating" the discussion of Russia's history and noted that the preparations for the 100th anniversary of the 1917 revolution should lead to reconciliation and not division.

A journalist from Znak.com asked why Putin said one thing but did another; Putin said she was too "categorical." The next reporter asked about Russian Orthodox activists who were in fact only driving people away from Orthodoxy by their actions, and the political elite was only "throwing down a challenge to Putin."

Putin asked to stop here. Then he called on both those showing exhibits and patriots to "show restraint". The reference was to extreme Orthodox activists who had demonstrated to shut down exhibits they thought were obscene or maligned the church or were unpatriotic, i.e. a photography exhibit at the Sakharov Center that showed among various conflicts and tragedies around the world, some photos from the war in Ukraine.

On State Oil and Gas Companies

Vedomosti  asked why revenue from Gazprom and Rosneft seems to lodge at Rosneftegaz, a state majority-owned company with stakes in both companies, doesn't find its way to the budget. Putin insisted that Rosneftegaz was "absolutely transparent" and said the company finances sciences and education when the government  cannot do so.

The question was asked because Rosneftegaz is the entity that will receive the funds from the sale of 19.5% of Rosneft's shares, in a deal which has raised a lot of questions because it is not clear where the entire amount of financing referenced by Sechin is available and where it will come from.

On the Bridge over the Kerch Straits and Other Construction Projects

Typical of the fluffy questions was one about the naming of the Kerch Straits bridge being built to forcibly-annexed Crimea by the Russian occupation authorities. There has been some discussion that it would be named after Putin. Recently, strong winds caused construction work on the project to be halted, and in general it faces engineering and political challenges.

A reporter from Yamala asked when construction would start on the long-promised North Latitude Corridor, and Putin said when the time was right.

On Putin's Next Run for Presidency

The Wall Street Journal's Nathan Hodge asked if there would be elections next year. The next presidential elections are scheduled for 2018, but there has been widespread speculation that Putin would move them to 2017 to ensure his victory.

"In which country?" Putin joked.

Then he replied it was "possible" but "not expedient."

-- Catherine A. Fitzpatrick 

X

Acknowledgements